Gorilla Journal 22, June 2001
Mountain Gorilla Tourism: Some Costs and Benefits
Conservationists mobilized in 1979 when plans were announced to clear
a large area of the Volcanoes National Park in Rwanda for cattle grazing,
since conversion of the forest habitat was considered the greatest threat
to the mountain gorillas' survival. A means of making the gorillas "pay
for themselves" and protecting the park was needed, so a tourism
program was planned and developed by researchers with experience gained
from the Karisoke Research Center, Amy Vedder and Bill Weber. The Mountain
Gorilla Project initiated the tourism program in Rwanda and gorilla
tourism has since become a great success in terms of increased protection
of the parks, close surveillance of additional gorilla groups and much
needed revenue.
Daily observations of the gorillas have facilitated rapid intervention
when necessary, for example, to remove snares. With increased protection
from poachers, more infants survived in groups that were habituated for
research or tourism and in the 1980s the gorilla population was increasing
for the first time in 3 decades.
Revenue from gorilla tourism helps cover salaries and operating costs
in all the protected areas of Rwanda. In addition, international publicity
surrounding the gorillas and the advent of organized tourism brought many
visitors to Rwanda and in the past made tourism the third-highest foreign
currency earner for this country, after tea and coffee. International
awareness and concern for plight of gorillas has been enhanced through
tourism and has generated funds for conservation activities and research.
The gorilla has become a national symbol and today the Rwandese passport,
visas for foreigners, and bank notes all feature gorillas.
Some Dangers Linked to Tourism. Tourism does have drawbacks. Even
before tourism began, impacts of human visits on the gorillas' behavior
were feared, such as changes in their ranging patterns, impeding the transfer
of females to other groups, and hindering reproduction. Stress to the
animals can be provoked during the habituation process or through regular
contact with unfamiliar humans, which could potentially result in immuno-suppression
or reduction in reproductive success. These impacts have never been adequately
evaluated. Fortunately, extrapolation from research on population demographics
carried out at Karisoke Research Center, indicates that tourism has not
been deleterious to the gorillas' overall health, behavior and ecology.
Any negative impacts seem to have been outweighed by the improved monitoring
and protection.
Until recently, we relied on speculation, extrapolation, and common sense
to evaluate the risks of disease transmission from humans to gorillas.
Tourism introduced a new element to these risks. A study by Jaco
Homsy, commissioned by the International Gorilla Conservation Programme
(IGCP), reviewed tourism regulations in light of epidemiological data
and the risk of disease transmission between people and gorillas. Studies
of captive gorillas show they have a definite susceptibility to human
diseases, but not the same resistance as humans. As a result of this shared
susceptibility, certain human pathogens can affect gorillas - respiratory
diseases (such as measles, herpes, pneumonia) and, equally important,
enteric diseases (such as polio, salmonella). Homsy concluded that "together
with the high population pressure surrounding the parks, disease exposure
ironically makes tourism one of the single greatest threats to mountain
gorilla survival" and that "the best hope for a least damaging
tourism program resides in the widespread sensitization, awareness and
understanding of the catastrophic consequences of unconscious gorilla
tourism."
With such a small population of gorillas in the Virungas, an infectious
disease could devastate the population, and gorilla eco-tourism has increased
the potential threat of disease transmission. While most of the international
tourists visiting Rwanda are fairly fit, having been inoculated against
certain diseases, they may be carrying viruses new to the region, such
as influenza. Illnesses to which the gorillas have never been exposed
are potentially the most dangerous. While this was recognized as a risk
at the start of the tourism program, the loss of habitat was considered
a far greater threat to the gorillas at the time and the tourism program
was implemented with rules to regulate tourist visiting times and the
number of tourists per group.
It is important to minimize stress and risks to the gorillas - no one
can afford to endanger their survival. Consequently, there are important
rules regarding the distance to be maintained between gorillas and visitors,
the number of visitors per group and a strict one-hour limit to the visit.
A conscientious tourist should never attempt to get closer than the regulation
7 m, or worse still, to touch a gorilla!
Despite the dangers inherent in tourism, it provides a mechanism for ensuring
that the parks and the gorillas are valued for many reasons, and has probably
saved the gorillas in the Virunga Volcanoes from further habitat loss
or degradation.
Why is the Cost of a "Gorilla Permit" so high? The cost of a
gorilla viewing permit is often questioned. It is currently US$ 250, and
most visitors will tell you it was worth every penny! There is a very
important reason for keeping the price high - it is a necessary means
to try to control the high pressures put upon the gorillas and the park
authorities. The gorillas are pretty much at their limit in terms of the
number of people who can visit them each day, and at certain times of
year it is hard to get a booking.
An important means of coping with demand and to assure parks and governments
of adequate revenue is to increase the cost of a visit to gorillas. At
US$ 250, gorilla viewing is affordable to almost all overseas visitors,
and few people are discouraged by the price. The mountain gorilla population
is too small and too fragile to withstand increased pressure from tourism.
Even with high fees, numbers of visitors do not diminish, but some of
the pressure subsides, while the revenue accrued by each governing authority
increases. It should never be forgotten that the tourism program was begun
first and foremost as a means of conserving the gorillas.
Liz Williamson
Dr. Liz Williamson studied gorillas
in Gabon from 1984 until 1990, when she became the Director of the Nyungwe
Forest Conservation Project, Rwanda. She was involved in gorilla surveys
in Congo/Zaire and Cameroon in 1994 and 1995. Until the end of 2001 she
was the Director of the Karisoke Research Centre.
Tourism overview
Homepage |